Kagn Dogs

Australian Shepherd vs Border Collie

Australian Shepherd
Australian Shepherd

Photo: Christoph Aeschlimann, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Border Collie
Border Collie

Photo: Horacio Cambeiro, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How the Australian Shepherd and the Border Collie compare: their size and lifespan, and the trait scores from 1 to 5 that Kagn Dogs gives every breed.

Australian ShepherdBorder Collie
SizeMediumMedium
Weight16–32 kg14–20 kg
Height46–58 cm46–56 cm
LifespanAbout 14 yearsAbout 13 years
OriginUnited StatesEngland, Scotland

Where they differ

The two breeds score much alike: no trait differs by two points or more. The small differences:

  • The Australian Shepherd sheds a little more than the Border Collie.
  • The Australian Shepherd suits a flat a little better than the Border Collie.
  • The Australian Shepherd is a little more wary of strangers than the Border Collie.

Traits side by side

Australian ShepherdBorder Collie
Energy 5 5
Shedding 4 3
Grooming 3 3
Barking 3 3
Trainability 5 5
Young children 3 3
Other dogs 3 3
Cats and small pets 3 3
Apartment 2 1
Time alone 2 2
Heat 3 3
Cold 4 4
Drooling 1 1
First-time owner 2 2
Watchdog 4 3

Scores from 1 to 5 are tendencies of the breed, not a promise about one dog.

About the Australian Shepherd

Though called Australian, this herding breed took shape in 19th-century California. The name is said to come from the collies that arrived alongside sheep imported from Australia.

About the Border Collie

Bred on the border of England and Scotland to herd sheep, and known for "the eye": a fixed, crouching stare it uses to move a flock.

Is your dog an Australian Shepherd or a Border Collie? Scan a photo to see which breeds it looks most like.

Scan a photo of your dog

Read more